{"contract_version":"1.4.0","rubric_version":"1.0.0","archetype_version":"1.1.0","skill_version":"0.2.0","tier":"deep","judge_model":"sonnet","judge_effort":"medium","commit_sha":"b41ddbfcbdad4e9ea5f3273299122c4d1a373608","filed_at":"2026-07-23T01:44:55.462Z","repo":{"owner":"plausible","name":"analytics","default_branch":"master"},"purpose":{"what_its_for":["privacy-first web analytics","GDPR/CCPA-compliant traffic tracking","self-hosted or managed Google Analytics alternative"],"purpose_statement":"An open source, cookie-free web analytics platform offered as a managed cloud service or a self-hosted community edition.","audience":"developers and businesses wanting privacy-compliant site analytics without third-party data sharing","category_candidates":["web-analytics","privacy-tech","self-hosted-app","google-analytics-alternative"],"archetype":"app"},"scores":{"axes":{"concept":{"score":7.5,"grade":"A","rationale_ref":"src-assets-js-dashboard-stats-graph-intervals-ts"},"usefulness":{"score":8,"grade":"AA","rationale_ref":"vitals-readme"},"ergonomics":{"score":7,"grade":"A","rationale_ref":"src-assets-js-dashboard-components-combobox-js"},"maturity":{"score":6,"grade":"BBB","rationale_ref":"probe-cve"},"longevity":{"score":7.5,"grade":"A","rationale_ref":"health-static"},"openness":{"score":7.5,"grade":"A","rationale_ref":"health-static"},"setup_friction":{"score":6,"grade":"BBB","rationale_ref":"vitals-readme"},"issue_health":{"score":5,"grade":"BB","rationale_ref":"health-static"},"supply_chain":{"score":4,"grade":"B","rationale_ref":"probe-deps"},"hype_substance":{"score":7,"grade":"A","rationale_ref":"probe-claim-5"}},"rollups":{"dependability":5.7,"craftsmanship":6.9,"docs":6.7,"trust":6.3},"composite":6.7,"grade":"BBB","recommendation":"TRIAL","confidence":"medium"},"summary":{"context_line":"Audited from a 0k-token evidence dossier; 4 files read, 13 probes answered.","intro":["Plausible Analytics is an open source, privacy-first web analytics tool offered as a paid managed cloud service or a self-hosted AGPL-3.0 community edition [vitals-readme].","Pull request throughput looks healthy — 74% of sampled merges came from external authors and 95% carried at least one review, with a 1.7-day median time-to-merge [health-static] — while the open-issue backlog tells a different story, with 63% of open issues stale beyond 180 days [health-static]."],"knocks":[{"lead":"The open-issue queue is largely dormant.","text":"63% of the 24 open issues are stale beyond 180 days, and no first-response time could be measured in the sampled window [health-static].","refs":["health-static"]},{"lead":"A couple of marketing claims don't trace to code.","text":"The '2-minute cloud setup' and '~32K datacenter IP exclusion' claims returned no strong code match in retrieval, leaving the anti-bot filtering pitch unverified [probe-claim-5][probe-claim-6].","refs":["probe-claim-5","probe-claim-6"]}],"holds_up":[{"lead":"Contribution flow is healthy and externally driven.","text":"External authors account for 74% of sampled merged PRs, 95% carried at least one review, and median time-to-merge is 1.7 days, indicating an active review culture rather than a rubber-stamp process [health-static].","refs":["health-static"]},{"lead":"The dashboard code backing the pitch is real and deliberately structured.","text":"Core UI logic such as the combobox filter component and interval-selection logic is cleanly factored [src-assets-js-dashboard-components-combobox-js][src-assets-js-dashboard-stats-graph-intervals-ts], and the most central module (segments.ts) is exercised by 15 test files [probe-top-tested].","refs":["src-assets-js-dashboard-components-combobox-js","src-assets-js-dashboard-stats-graph-intervals-ts","probe-top-tested"]},{"lead":"License and community documentation are unambiguous.","text":"AGPL-3.0 is clearly declared [probe-license], and the repository's community health files (code of conduct, contributing guide, PR template) score 87% complete [health-static].","refs":["probe-license","health-static"]}],"bottom_line":"A mature, well-reviewed privacy analytics app with strong PR discipline but a largely neglected issue tracker."},"use_cases":[{"use_case":"self-hosted Google Analytics alternative for GDPR/CCPA compliance","fit":"strong","note":"Explicitly built for EU-hosted, cookie-free compliance with a self-hosted community edition [vitals-readme]."},{"use_case":"cookie-free analytics for a marketing or SaaS website","fit":"strong","note":"Lightweight tracker script, goal/conversion tracking, and real-time dashboard are core features [vitals-readme]."},{"use_case":"team analytics with role-based sharing and Slack/email reports","fit":"strong","note":"Team invitations and role-based access are implemented in the codebase [probe-claim-4]."},{"use_case":"enterprise deployment needing a formal support SLA","fit":"partial","note":"Managed cloud exists but no SLA/support commitments are evidenced in the dossier.","instead":"a paid enterprise analytics vendor with contractual SLAs"},{"use_case":"lightweight embeddable tracking snippet for a single SPA","fit":"poor","note":"This is a full self-hosted/cloud application with a large codebase, not a minimal client-side library.","instead":"a standalone JS analytics tracker library"}],"alternatives_note":"For only a client-side tracking snippet rather than a full self-hosted app, a lightweight analytics library is a better fit."}